ENGL-145 - Reasoning, Argumentation and Writing

The principles of reasoning in argumentation. Examination of rhetorical principles and responsible rhetorical behavior. Application of these principles to written and oral communications. Effective use of research methods and sources.

peitho goddess of persuasion
The Greek Goddess of Persuasion, Peitho

***
Section 01, MW 12:10-2:00 in 22-314
Instructor: Steven Marx
phone: 756-2411
smarx@calpoly.edu
http://cla.calpoly.edu/~smarx
Office: 47-25E (Faculty Office Building)
Office hours: MW 2:10-3:30

***

Issues of Sustainability
with special reference to the Cal Poly Campus

Winter 2008 Schedule

Week Date Topic Class activity Work due
I 1/7

Rhetoric and argument

Argument and sustainability

logos, pathos, ethos

Introduction

Case Study: An Inconvenient Truth[AIT] (25 minutes)

Analysis and discussion

 

 
  1/9

Logos:

Sentence, Paragraph, Argument

Toulmin and other models of logical argument.

Watch AIT (second 35 minutes)

Small group discussion

Topics

Start writing

Study:

  1. The Toulmin Model (I)

  2. The Toulmin Model (II)

Watch AIT complete

 

II 1/14

Pathos and Ethos

Propaganda and advertising

AIT--the last part and ancillary material

Discuss Paper 1

"Easter in Las Vegas"

Paper 1--Reaction to AIT [due Sunday 6pm-- as Word attachment by email] 

  1/16

The AIT Controversy

Evaluating arguments

Qualifiers and refutations

 

Small group discussion: Whom to believe?

Discuss paper 1

Study

Pro and Anti AIT articles and websites

III 1/21-holiday    

 

 

  1/23

Fallacies

Class notes

Analyzing fallacies and perceived fallacies

"The Great Global Warming Swindle"

Study

"Mediarology": The Roles of Citizens, Journalists, and Scientists in Debunking Climate Change Myths

Wikipedia on AIT

Wikipedia on "The Great Global Warming Swindle"

"Swindled" --RealClimate review of "The Great Global Warming Swindle"

Fallacies

Quiz: the vocabulary of argumentation

IV 1/28

no class

 

Wikipedia on AIT

 

 

Paper 2--AIT Reconsidered [due Sunday 6 pm-- as Word attachment by email]

  1/30

Discuss Paper 2

Introduce OOO

 

Prepare for Focus the Nation

 

  1/31 FtN Attend Focus the Nation event    
V 2/4 Focus the Nation Debrief   Paper #3 Focus the Nation--critique and response [due Sunday 6pm-- as Word attachment by email] 
  2/6

Evaluating sources of information.

Paper 4 assigned

 

Learning about Wikipedia; comparing sources, strengths and weaknesses

Discuss Papers 2 and 3

Wikipedia on Wikipedia

Wired magazine article

Outline of Wired article

New Yorker magazine article

VI 2/11 Contributing to human knowledge

Discuss Papers 2 and 3

Creating a new entry to Wikipedia

 

Study

Your first article

Article development

Creating an account

Guide to writing better articles

Tutorial on formatting

Picture tutorial

 

  2/13

Collaborative research

Meet in Library computer lab 111B

Wikipedia research workshop

 

Your first article

Article development

Creating an account

Guide to writing better articles

Tutorial on formatting

Picture tutorial


VII 2/18

Developing Wikipedia article

 

Meet in Library computer lab 111B

Wikipedia research workshop



 
  2/20 Definition: understanding concepts, defining terms

Sustainability
--in Education
--at Cal Poly and CSU

Paper 5--Research proposal [due 6:00 Wednesday 2/27 as Word attachment by email]

Study

"Sustainability" in Brittanica, US EPA Wikipedia

The Talloires Declaration

 

  2/22     Paper 4-- Wikipedia entry [due online Friday 6:00 p.m.]
VIII 2/25 Primary and secondary research

Cal Poly documents and controversies

Student guest lecturers:

 

Study

Resources on Sustainability at Cal Poly

  2/27  

Generating topics on issues

Discuss proposals

Paper 5--Research proposal [due 6:00A.M as Word attachment by email]
IX 3/3     Revision of Wikipedia articles due
  3/5     Paper 6--Research essay first draft[due 6:00A.M as Word attachment by email]
X 3/10   Conferences and peer feedback Final versions of Wikipedia. articles due for grading 6:00 AM
  3/12   Conferences and peer feedback  
XI Final Exam

3/17

Monday10:10-1:00

  Research Paper Presentations Paper 7--Final draft due in electronic and hard copy

Workload and Grading

Paper 1: An Inconvenient Truth response 750 words 10%
Quiz   5%
Paper 2: An Inconvenient Truth reconsidered 1000 words 15%
Paper 3: Focus the Nation response 750 words 10%
Paper 4: Wikipedia group project (3 members) 750 words each 15%
Paper 5: Research proposal 350 words 5%
Paper 6: First draft research paper 1250 words 15%
Paper 7: Final draft research paper 1250 words 25%

Course Materials

Most course materials will be available online. The texts we focus on for the first few weeks, An Inconvenient Truth, and The Great Global Warming Swindle are available on 4-hour reserve at the Library.

For writing tips see Dr. Marx's Special Formula for Improved Grades on English Papers

For a complete guide to solving writing problems, see Our Own Online Rhetoric and Style Manual (OOO)

Strongly recommended for discussions and research on issues of Sustainability at Cal Poly is Cal Poly Land: A Field Guide, edited by Steven Marx. It's available for purchase online or at El Corral Bookstore.