Russia's shattering defeat in the Crimean war in 1856 brought about
the political decision to eliminate serfdom as the first step towards the selective
modernization of the Empire. The goal was the reassertion of traditional Russian
military might and international power in an era when shear weight of population
was no longer sufficient. But the autocracy was absolutely committed to the preservation
of the traditional political order and social structure. Given this inflexibility
the process was probably condemned to failure from the outset. The land distribution
that accompanied the emancipation of the serfs was inadequate for most peasants.
Redemption payments for the land received deprived them of a decent standard of
living and precluded the development of a rural market for consumer goods that
would be necessary for a broad-based modernization. Furthermore, land was not
given to individual peasant households, but rather to the traditional village-commune
(mir), which dampened any sense of individual initiative. In short, the
serf and land reforms failed to create a healthy and prosperous peasant sector
that could have been a conservative bulwark of a regime experiencing the stresses
of modernization.