Religion and the Struggle
for Political Modernization
Constitutionalism vs.
Absolutism.
- The Struggle for political
modernization.
- A question of sovereignty ---- absolutism vs. constitutionalism
----See McKay, 531-532
- "Religion is 16th
century word for nationalism."
- Religion seems
to be the issue in the upheavals in Netherlands, France and England.
- Religion as
a "cloak" covering a complex of factors.
- Reactionary
- Modernization
- Sometimes both
- Proto-national character.
- Spain under the last
Habsburgs.
- The emergence of
Spain as a new/absolute national monarchy. See Centennia,
compare 1000 with 1470 with 1550
- Reconquista
- Consolidation or royal vs. aristocratic power:
- Hermandades
- Royal bureaucracy
- Royal army
- National Church
- A world empire:
why?
- "While
other nations wage war; you, happy Austria, you marry." Click
here for chart on for the
background of Habsburg Hausmacht, e.g. Centennia,
1475, 1527
- Cortez, Pizzarro,
Magellan
- The division of
Habsburg Hausmacht.
- Philip II 1556-1598:
- Click on
the photo of Escorial.

- "Most
Catholic King" and his crusade ---- parallel to internal
upheaval in England, France and HRE
- Decline under
Philip III (1598-1622),
- Philip IV (1622-1665).
See summary in McKay, p. 548
- Charles II
(1665-1700) unleashes the War of Spanish Succession, 1701-1714 with
the ultimate result of a Bourbon monarchy
- The Dutch Revolt against
Spanish Absolutism.
- A division:
- 17 Provinces
divided by economics, religion, language, culture and political rule
- Political unity
came only through the union of Burgundy and Habsburg. Click on Maximilian
for a chart.

- The revolt was a
blend of religion, economics and politics.
- William the
Silent (Orange) and the "Beggars" 1566-- a revolt against Philip II's
grasp at political and economic modernization under the "cloak" of
Spanish Catholicism.
- Philip's Response
- Alba (1567-73).
- Council
of Troubles
- Calvinism
became germ of a kind of modern, political nationalism
- . 1573-78
-- Alba replaced by a series of governors.
- Spanish
atrocities.
- Pacification
of Ghent 1576
- Duke of
Parma --- 1578 brought a reconciliation with the Catholics that
split the resistence.
- The Birth of the
Dutch Republic in the north and the reconsolidation of the Catholic South.
For a map history of the progression of the Dutch Revolt, click here.
See also Centennia, 1578-1580.4.
-
League of
Arras, 1579 --- united loyal Catholics with the Spanish crown
-
Union of Utrecht,
1579---military union of 7 provinces of the North ---- began population
transfers.
-
Act of Abjuration,
1581: Implict constitutionalism. What is
constitutionalism? See McKay, 548.
- Effective Independence
by the 1580's
- Together with the
English against Philip.
- Mary Queen of
Scots, 1587
- The "Sea
Hawks," the Armada, 1588 and its consequences.
- A
New Nation: The Dutch Republic as a reflection of its history.
- Government.
- Confederation
to 1618.
- The impact
of the Thirty Years War, 1618-1648.
- Patrician
Regency, 1648-1672.
- Preeminence in
commerce and banking ---- world-wide empire. See
map in McKay, 559.
- Religious
Tolerance and Economic Prosperity.
- "A Golden
Age."
- Decline and transition
towards monarchy.
- The Navigation
Wars: 1652-74
- The French
War 1672-78
- France from Anarchy
to Divine Right Monarchy.
- The struggle for
. "New Monarchy" 1453-1559
- Significance of
the 100 Years War 1337-1453. Compare Centennia
1423 with 1500
- Joan of Arc:
"national crusade on behalf of "French king" Charles
VII. FYI click here.
- Estates General
and the taille, 1439
- The Church
- Pragmatic
Sanction of Bourges. 1439. For description and summary of text
click here.
- Concordat
of Bologna, 1516.
- Structural feudalism
still in evidence. See W-R-W, p. 39.
- Aristocratic
spheres of influence.
- The Protestant
Reformation as a cloak
for other motives.
- Persistence
of regional identities.
- The Religious Wars
1559-1589.
- Era of weak monarchs
after the death of Henry I in 1559
- Manipulation of
Catherine d' Medici
- . E.g.St.
Barthomew Day Massacre, August 1572. Click here
for a painting and a florid description with dramatically exaggerated
historical parallels.
- War of Three
Henries (1574-1589)
- Absolutism as a solution
for anarchy.
- The Politiques.
- Jean Bodin.
Read: W-R-W, 42, 46-47.
- What is sovereignty?
See McKay, 531.
- For
Bodin, what is its principle function? (W-R-W,
46) Who should exercize it?
(W-R-W, 47)
- The Trend Towards
Absolutism: 1589-1643
- The Brilliance
of Henry IV (1589-1610)
- The
Edict of Nantes, 1598 made Catholicism the state religion,
but granted privileges to the Hugonots. See
articles 6, 7, 8, 9, 16, 27 in the excerpts accessible here.
- Estates General
never called.
- Economic policy
under Henry and Sully, McKay, 534.
- Absolutism
as a positive experience under Henry.
- Louis XIII 1610-1643
- The Regency
of Marie d' Medici 1610-1617.
- The three policies
of Richelieu Read the following links:
- Aristocracy.
- Huguenots.
- The Habsburgs
- The last gasp
of the feudal aristocracy --- the Fronde 1648-1652
- Young Louis XIV
and Reconsolidation under Mazarin, 1643-1661
- The Age of Louis
XIV 1643-1715
- Hegemony in Europe
- Political:
weakness in Central Europe and Civil War in England
- Economic:
mercantilism successful in pre-industrial age.
- Cultural:--
Academie francais founded by Richelieu, standardization of
language.
- Child King: 1643-1661
- The reactionary
revolt of the Fronde (1648-52)
- Who had
lost power under Richelieu? See links above.
- Failure:
---- see McKay, p. 537.
- Mazarin and
the restoration of the legacy of Richelieu
- Louis, "The
Sun King."
- What does this
portrait and the description by St. Simon in W-R-W, 49-53 about
the ceremony with which he surrounded his person tell us about Louis'
view of government? In a passage not in the readings,
Bossuet wrote: "The prince,
as prince, is not to be regarded as a private individual; he is a
public personage; all the State is in him; the will of all the people
is contained in his." L' etat c'est moi, said
Louis.

- Contrast the justification
for royal sovereignty put forth by Jacques Bossuet. Read:
W-R-W, 47-49 with that of Jean Bodin and applied by Henry IV.
- What is the
purpose for the existence of the King as the sovereign in contrast
with that of Bodin?
- What are the
three essential characteristics of royal authority?
- The
Pageant of Versailles and its political purpose. Click on the photo below
for a photo-tour.

For additional examples
click Versailles
- Colbert
and economic policy. Read mercantilism
and McKay, 539-540.
- Religious
policy: The
Revocation of the Edict of Nantes, 1685
- The
Wars of Louis XIV.
- Devolution, 1667-1668
---- against Spanish Netherlands. ----
- Against Spanish
Netherlands and Holy Roman Empire, 1672-1679.
- War of the League
of Augsburg, 1688-1697 against Austrian and Spanish Habsburgs, Sweden,
Bavaria, Saxony, the Palatinate and, after 1689, England ---- aiming
at consolidation of French territory up to the Rhine..
- The Spanish Succession,
1701-1713 (Queen Anne's War in North America) --- against England, Austrian
Habsburgs, Netherlands and Prussia was one of the first "balance
of power" wars.
- The Consequences:
- Territorial consolidation.
See Centennia 1672-1714.
- Financial Crisis as one cause of the Revolution of 1789.
- Poll tax imposed on all ---- combined with bad harvests 1688-94
produce wide resentment.
- Weaknesses of mercantilism
- England from feudal
monarchy to "New Monarchy" to Constitutionalism.
- Medieval constitutionalism
to New Monarchy.
- The "golden
age" of feudal constitutionalism and the 100 Years War --- opposite
impact than in France.
- The construction
of a "new monarchy" in response to feudal chaos of the War of the Roses,
1453-1485.
- The Tudors and the
onset of "New Monarchy
- Henry VII (Tudor).(1485-1509)
- Frugality ---
avoidance of war ---- flourishing of commerce.
- Sparing use
of parliament.
- Royal Council prepared laws ---- then just registered by
Parliament
- Council (Star Chamber) applied Roman Law
- Shire (iffs) --- applied royal law
- Henry VIII (1509-1547):
Reformation
----
- The Church as
an element of "New Monarchy."
- Nationalization
of Church lands and the creation of a new, dependent aristocracy --
- The Irish Settlement.
.
- Elizabeth (1558-1603)
-- "velvet glove" absolutism.
- The Elizabethan
Settlement (39 Acts of 1563) provided the environment for the "golden
age" of the English Renaissance.
- A kind of national
unity requiring conformity with the Anglican Church under the monarch
as its titular head.
- Actual toleration.
- In Scotland,
Calvinist John Knox won the support of the Scottish barons against the
Catholic Mary Queen of Scots, ended papal authority and made the monarchy
(James VI) subject to their parliament.
- The Tudor Legacy.
- The survival
of Parliament.
- The religious
situation on the eve of the 17th century. Diversity!
- The factions.
- Religion as
a cloak for two conflicting versions of modernization.
- The economic
situation.
- Acceleration
of commercial capitalism ---- resultant social change and desires
for political power.
- Social-Economic
Situation: Read McKay, 549-550.
- The Enclosure
Movement
- Transformation
of the gentry.
- Impact
on the yoemen farmers
- The Constitutional
Crisis of the Stuarts: 1603-1649.
- Monarchy vs. Parliament
-- two conflicting concepts of modernization.
- James I (1603-1625).
From "honeymoon" to "irreconcilable differences"
- James' view
of monarchy. Read: "The
Trew Law of Free Monarchies."
- Parliament's
view of monarchy.
- Clash made inevitable
by the rampant inflation of the price revolution.
- Foreign
policy blunder
- Parliament's
"Great Protestation" of 1621 asserted the traditional
right of power over the purse-strings. -- fiscal demands --- James'
response.
- Charles I (1625-1649)
- Petetion of
Right. 1628.
- Charles' grasp
at absolutism 1628-1640. A fusion of political, economic and religious
issues.
- E.g. Ships
Money.
- Archbishop
Laud. --- revolt in Scottland, 1639.
- The "Short Parliament"
1640
- The "Long Parliament"
and the Civil War 1640-49.
- Painting of the
execution
of Charles I, January 30, 1649.
- The English Commonwealth
1649-1660.
- FYI:
Hobbes
and the Leviathan, 1651: the issue of sovereignty. Read:
McKay, 551.
- Cromwell ---
republicanism into dictatorship.
- "The Restoration"
1660-1688
- The religious settlement
-- The Test Act of 1673.
- Property legislation.
- Modernization
- Confiscations of Interregnum
- Some restoration
- Recognition of
seizures ----- basis of Whig Party
- The Reign of Charles
II, 1660-1685.
- "CABAL"
and the roots of cabinet government.
- Secret Treaty
of Dover (1670) with France against the Netherlands was a source
of hostility and one of the origins of the power of impeachment
in the U.S. Constitution.
- The Catholic
Question
- James II (1685-1688)
and the "Glorious Revolution"
- Declaration
of Indulgences, 1687
- The succession
issue and the "whispering campaign."
- Constitutional Monarchy
and the "Whig Oligarchy."
- FYI:
The Bill of Rights, 1689. See McKay, 554.
- Read
McKay, 554. FYI
John Locke and the Second
Treatise on Civil Government, 1690.
- Act
of Settlement, 1701..
- The Battle of
Boyne, 1690 -- the last serious threat of the "Jacobites."
- Formation of
the United Kingdom, 1707.
- The "Georges"
(I -1714-27; II-1727-1760; III-1760-1820) and Walpole (1721-1742): The
development of cabinet government and responsible ministry under Walpole,
see, McKay, 554.
The Baroque and the Age
of Absolutism. Video: "The Baroque, 1545-1715. Click here
for the text. For access to web reproductions of many of the paintings shown
in the video, click here.
[home][syllabus][outline][notices][notices
archive][quiz analysis][links]